June 26, 2018

Hicks Thomas Wins Appeal in East Texas Mineral Rights Dispute

By Hicks Thomas LLP


TEXARKANA, Texas – Hicks Thomas lawyers won a Texas appeals court ruling for MJR Oil & Gas 2001 LLC involving a dispute over dozens of East Texas leases.

What are Mineral Rights in Texas?

In the state of Texas, mineral rights are regarded as the rights to mineral deposits that are beneath the surface of someone’s property. Generally, this right belongs to the owner of the property, but there is an opportunity for these rights to be transferred by sale or by leasing them to a second party.

Details of the Complex Case

Firm lawyers successfully argued to the 6th Court of Appeals in Texarkana that MJR’s right of first refusal was a covenant running with the land. The ruling reversed the summary judgment granted by the trial court in Longview and sent the case back for trial.

“We’re very pleased for our client. There is a considerable amount at stake, since the ruling affects our client’s rights in numerous oil and gas leases,” said Hicks Thomas appellate lawyer J. Stephen Barrick of Houston. Also representing Dallas-based MJR is firm co-founder John B. Thomas, and attorneys Jody Sheets and Jason Gunderman.

The appeals court held that a 2002 settlement agreement referenced in a recorded assignment of overriding royalty interests giving MJR a right of first refusal on any sale of the leases was a covenant running with the land that was binding on the original parties’ successors and assigns. Some of the successors failed to comply with MJR’s first-refusal rights, and that is what led to the lawsuit against AriesOne, GFP Texas Inc., Miken Oil Inc. and SND Energy Co.

“The ruling was important because the court clarified that a right of first refusal in an oil and gas lease can be a covenant running with the land, even if it is not described with those words,” said Mr. Thomas. “This is a big win for our client.”

Also representing MJR Oil & Gas are P. Michael Jung and Jadd Masso of Clark Hill Strasburger in Dallas. David Henry of Stevens Henry in Longview was local counsel in the trial court. The case is MJR Oil & Gas 2001 LLC v. AriesOne LP, et al., Case No. 06-00116-CV in the Texas 6th Court of Appeals.

Founded in 1997, Texas-based Hicks Thomas LLP is a premier litigation firm representing plaintiffs and defendants across the nation with offices in Houston, Austin, Beaumont and Amarillo, Texas, and Sacramento, California. The firm provides in-depth experience in cases involving oil and gas, environmental, complex commercial, toxic tort, construction, products liability, corporate governance, securities, banking, insurance coverage, transportation, trade secrets and business litigation. Visit the firm at http://www.hicks-thomas.com.

Related Posts

Attorney Client Privilege Protects Non-Retained Expert Communications

The Houston 14th Court of Appeals issued an opinion today, in-re-texas-windstorm, which will solidify and strengthen the strategy of using one’s clients as experts to prove the reasonableness of conduct by insurers in first party bad faith and coverage disputes. The ruling applies to virtually every other civil lawsuit in…

Full Text

State Farm v. Richards Analysis

In State Farm Lloyds v. Richards, No. 19-0802 (3/20/2020), the Supreme Court of Texas answered a certified question from the U.S. Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals on the “eight-corners rule,” rejecting a federal district court’s recognition of an exception to the rule. The eight-corners rule is an analytical tool that Texas…

Full Text

Hicks Thomas Lawyers Win Take-Nothing Jury Verdict for Houston Manufacturer

Worker had sued for up to $1 million, but Facebook photos undercut his story HOUSTON – A judge has confirmed a jury’s take-nothing verdict in favor of a Houston-based manufacturer that was sued for damages of up to $1 million by a worker who was injured when he improperly tried…

Full Text

Call: 713-547-9100